A virus’ journey: what does corona teach us about Africa’s global connections?

Mayke Kaag is a senior researcher at the African Studies Centre Leiden. She is the convenor of the Collaborative Research Group Africa in the world: Rethinking Africa's global connections and chair of the Research Master in African Studies.
 

It is only two weeks ago (although it seems much longer as I am writing this) that I was preparing a trip to Benin and very much looking forward to meeting my colleagues in Cotonou. Even though the corona virus had already made inroads into Europe, in the Netherlands we were still quite relaxed. I was therefore rather disappointed when I received the news that the government of Benin had decided that every traveller from Europe was obliged to stay in quarantine for 14 days upon arrival. This meant that I had to cancel my trip…. At the same time, I thought it was quite cool that now Africans were blocking Europeans from entering their country, instead of the other way around. The world upside down! I liked it.

Why has Africa been so little affected to date?
Now, a couple of weeks later, the world has taken on a gloomier outlook. Looking at the map of corona infections worldwide it is clear that the pandemic is spreading like wildfire. But why is Africa so little affected in comparison to other regions of the globe? Why does it still have relatively few cases? A quick search shows that there are different theories in this regard. Some sources argue that Covid-19 does not thrive in a warm climate, hence the relative absence of the virus in Africa. This theory is not uncontested, however. Other sources find an explanation in African genes: Africans would be more more resistant to the virus. A medical doctor working for the World Health Organization pointed to the experience African governments have in dealing with emergencies like this, as they have dealt with Ebola in the recent past, and hailed the measures at international airports and effective collaboration between African governments. Other experts, by contrast, point to weak monitoring systems, especially in rural areas and those with limited technology, and ask whether the current relative absence of the virus in Africa is simply a case of under-reporting.

Africa’s global connections
I am not in a position to evaluate the foregoing claims, and that is not the purpose of this piece either. What I would like to do here is call attention to another aspect that is crucial in my view: the influence of Africa’s global connections. In the early days of the virus’ journey, when it was still largely restricted to China, observers forecast that the spread would hit Africa hard. The close relations between China and the African continent in combination with the weak healthcare systems in Africa would lead to a disastrous situation. While this argument makes sense at first sight, the forecast has thus far not materialised - so we need to think better. The answer lies in a more in-depth analysis of Africa’s global connections, and that is what is being provided in an article by The Africa Report.

Flows of people
The article puts it bluntly: it is Africa’s global connectedness, stupid! Africa is simply less connected to the rest of the world, including China, especially in terms of flows of people. Thus, it is mentioned that global tourism flows to Africa are only five per cent, with only a meagre four per cent of China’s tourists heading to Africa. Flows of workers to Africa are also fairly insignificant. Contrary to received ideas, even the proportion of Chinese workers going to Africa is relatively low: of the Chinese workers going abroad in 2017, only 16 per cent were employed in Africa. To this, I would like to add that African migration out of the continent is also restricted to a great extent, in contrast to what certain media and politicians want us to believe.

Tourism
Further evidence to support the above argument is the fact that, until now, the African countries most hit by Covid-19 are those that have relatively more developed tourism sectors, more international residents, and a higher proportion of transnational linkages through global migration, such as South Africa and Senegal.
The article underlines that the spread of the current corona virus to Africa shows exactly the same pattern as other major viruses originating outside of Africa in recent history. For example, the SARS outbreak in 2002/2003 only hit Africa five months after its initial outbreak in China. In the same vein, the H1N1 outbreak that started in Mexico in 2009 reached Africa rather late and, ultimately, the number of deaths from the virus in Africa were one per cent of the total deaths worldwide.

Uneven linkages
The current corona crisis is revealing just how interconnected our world is. Perhaps more interesting, it also shows how continents, countries and localities are differently connected, and differently integrated in the global economy and in the global movement of people. The virus’ journey is reiterating James Ferguson’s[1] point (mentioned in one of my previous blogs), namely that globalisation is not simply about unfettered and even connection but is made up of uneven linkages in terms of intensity, flows, and associated power relations.

Infectious solidarity
It appears that ongoing ‘social distancing’ of Africa(ns) at a global level has, to date, saved the continent from a strong invasion by Covid-19.  Let us hope that this ‘social distancing’ will indeed help to ‘flatten the curve’ in Africa. Better still, that the continent will not be hit hard before a cure has come available. However, in view of the growth in cases over the last week, this is probably too optimistic an outcome, and experts point to the huge difficulties in fighting the virus in Africa, including lack of materials, knowledge, and basic facilities. Let us hope, then, that the encouraging and heart-warming local and national solidarity and support that have emerged across Europe in the context of the corona crisis, will extend to global solidarity. A virus’ injurious journey turned upside down – now, that would be great.


[1] Ferguson, J., 2006. Global Shadows. Africa in the neoliberal world order. Duke University Press.

This post has been written for the ASCL Africanist Blog. Would you like to stay updated on new blog posts? Subscribe here! Would you like to comment? Please do! The ASCL reserves the right to edit, shorten or reject submitted comments.

Also read the next blog, Corona in Ghana: a virus’ impact on society and academic life, written by Samuel Aniegye Ntewusu.

Top photo: screen shot of the realtime data map of the global spread of the Corona virus, situation 23 March 2020. Source: Johns Hopkins University.

Tags

Corona
COVID-19
World Health Organisation
Africa's global connections
tourism
social distancing
Benin
South Africa
Senegal
China

Comments

Add new comment

Organization/ affiliation: 
Institute of Social and Cultural Anthropology, Freie Universität Berlin

Thanks for this insightful piece.

Your point about uneven linkages is interesting. Air traffic to South Africa is extensive compared to other African countries (Kenya, Ethiopia and Nigeria also have a fair share). Both tourists and travelling South Africans in Europe have been the main cause of the increase in alarm and actual infection of COVID-19 in the country.

Over the past week, the South African case is showing that Africa will not be shielded from high infection rates stemming from travellers. As Rwanda, the country is in a strict lockdown from Thursday to try and slow the spread. This measure was taken to protect a huge part of the South African population with compromised immune systems, especially in townships.

It remains to be seen what will happen in other African countries, but South Africa is certainly seeing an increase in infections similar to the beginning stages of many European countries.

Organization/ affiliation: 
Self

Great article with great analysis and I like it. However, I beg to differ on the notion that one of challenges in fighting corona virus in Africa will be lack of knowledge. To the contrary I strongly believe it is the availability of knowledge in Africa that has become the best weapon to slow spread of corona virus. With internet and vernacular radio presence in even the most remote areas, information and knowledge about corona virus is spreading like wild fire as well.
Am writing this from a remote place in Kenya enjoying a 4G network which the government has just upgraded so people can more effectively receive information. Knowledge about the virus is also disseminated and experts are learning quickly from their colleagues in other countries. IT has played a great role in acquiring the relevant knowledge.
I agree lack of materials in Africa is a real challenge but availability of information and knowledge is the lifeline here.
Thank you
Joseph

Organization/ affiliation: 
Addis Ababa University

Dear Mayke,

I find your effort to make sense of why the spread of the coronavirus has become relatively low in Africa perceptive. There are guesses here and there, most in fragmentary forms. I find your assessment systematic and with new insights. Thank you for that.
I am writing this to share what has transpired here in Ethiopia.
I came back to Ethiopia from my visiting fellowship with the African Studies Centre Leiden on 19 March, two weeks before the initial plan, for the obvious reason. I am in self isolation in my own house; today is my seventh day. But I am in constant touch with people via phone and I follow the local news media. Lots of speculations. A few of the key guesses why the spread is/looks low:
1. Half jokingly, some say what we eat has a lot of red pepper (chili), spices, etc. and this will stand in the way of the coronavirus from spreading like it did/does in some other places.
2. Deeply religious people attribute it to divine intervention (those who believe in this, their number is not insignificant). The faithful leave the matter to God.
3. Weather...
4. Those subscribing to conspiracy theories: a few claim that the virus was a lab escapee, thus attacking those closer to the location of the lab, believing at once that the virus could be weakened when arriving in Africa.
5. Quite a few informed people (especially healthcare professionals) suspect that the worse may yet to come...

There is a saying in Ethiopia, which could be roughly translated “Let it be as you hoped.” So, I say that to you too for presenting a hopeful scenario.
Be this as it may, there seems to be little or no sensitivity to the coronavirus pandemic here. We don’t see any good preparation other than planning to quarantine people who come from Asia and Europe. (Not yet started, I guess. Officially announced on the 23rd of March by the Prime Minister.) Schools are of course closed since one week ago. However, the great majority of citizens do not seem to take some precautionary measures other than panicking.

Thanks again and stay safe!
Setargew Kenaw Fantaw
Addis Ababa, 25th of March, 2020.